2021
Discovery Education Science

6th to 8th Grade - Gateway 2

Back to 6th to 8th Grade Overview
Cover for Discovery Education Science
Note on review tool versions

See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.

Loading navigation...

Gateway Ratings Summary

Coherence & Scope

Gateway 2 - Partially Meets Expectations
73%
Criterion 2.1: Coherence and Full Scope of the Three Dimensions
41 / 56

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations for Gateway 2: Coherence & Scope; Criterion 1: Coherence and Full Scope of the Three Dimensions. Whereas materials only partially meet expectations for ten sub-indicators and do not meet for two, they do meet expectations for twelve sub-indicators in Gateway 2. The materials present two ways to sequence the units and provide guidelines if districts choose to reorganize differently. Yet, in addition to missing an increase in sophistication of tasks across the series, the materials do not include explicit connections of dimensions from unit to unit. For the scope of the three dimensions, all grade-band components of DCIs are incorporated with few elements partially addressed or omitted. With one SEP fully addressed, the materials either partially address or omit elements of the other seven SEPs. For each SEP, individual elements are repeatedly used across units within or across grade levels. For example, students use the practice of Engaging in Argument from Evidence in half of the units across the series, including each grade and science discipline, with the element ARG-M3 used most frequently. Most components of CCCs are incorporated with one (scale, proportion, and quantity) not meeting expectations and another only being partially addressed. For each CCC, individual elements are repeatedly used across units within or across grade levels. For example, students use the crosscutting concept of Energy and Matter in each grade and science discipline, with the greatest frequency in the physical science units. Lastly, materials incorporate most components and many elements of the grade-band NGSS connections to the nature of science and engineering.

Criterion 2.1: Coherence and Full Scope of the Three Dimensions

41 / 56

Materials are coherent in design, scientifically accurate, and support grade-band endpoints of all three dimensions.

NOTE: Indicators 2b-2c are non-negotiable; instructional materials being reviewed must score above zero points in each indicator, otherwise the materials automatically do not proceed to Gateway 3.

​The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations for the Criterion 2a-2g: Coherence and Full Scope of the Three Dimensions. Although the materials include recommendations for sequencing the units, they do not demonstrate how dimensions connect from unit to unit, nor do tasks increase in sophistication across the series. The materials are free of scientific inaccuracies and include science topics within grade-band DCIs. For the DCIs of earth and space sciences and engineering, technology, and applications of science, all grade-band components and their elements are incorporated; however, one element of physical science is partially addressed and a few elements of life science are only partially addressed or omitted. With one SEP fully addressed, the materials either partially address or omit elements of the other seven SEPs. For each SEP, individual elements are repeatedly used across units within or across grade levels. For example, students use the practice of Engaging in Argument from Evidence in half of the units across the series, including each grade and science discipline, with the element ARG-M3 used most frequently. Most components of CCCs are incorporated with one (scale, proportion, and quantity) not meeting expectations and another only being partially addressed. For each CCC, individual elements are repeatedly used across units within or across grade levels. For example, students use the crosscutting concept of Energy and Matter in each grade and science discipline, with the greatest frequency in the physical science units. Lastly, materials incorporate most components and many elements of the grade-band NGSS connections to the nature of science and engineering.

Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only

Indicator 2a

Narrative Only

Materials are designed for students to build and connect their knowledge and use of the three dimensions across the series.

Indicator 2a.i

0 / 2

Students understand how the materials connect the dimensions from unit to unit.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 do not meet expectations that students understand how the materials connect the dimensions from unit to unit. Materials do not connect dimensions from unit to unit for students nor do they provide support for teachers to help students understand those connections. Teachers are given information about various pathways that can be taken to teach the units and how they connect, but this information is in teacher material and not included in activity planning support. The activity planning support provides guidance and prompts for supporting student use of DCIs, SEPs, and CCCs at three different levels of proficiency: when students use them for the first time, if they are building toward proficiency, or if they have demonstrated proficiency. These prompts miss opportunities for students to make connections among prior use of SEPs, DCIs, and CCCs from other units or within the same unit. Units with a Driving Question Board consistently provide information to teachers in case students ask questions outside the scope of the phenomenon; however, the materials do not describe how the dimensions connect in the driving questions. Instead, materials suggest that teachers state to students that related topics will be covered in other units. 

Examples of missed opportunities to show connections between units:

  • In Grade 6, Unit 2: Levitating Forces, the materials do not demonstrate how the dimensions connect from unit to unit. Across the series, Units 1, 2, 3, 4, and 11 provide opportunities for students to study different types of forces and motion, potential energy, energy transfer in a system, gravity’s effect on motion, and electromagnetic waves respectively. The overview documents in the teacher materials for Unit 2 list connections to Units 1, 3, 4, and 11, but provide no guidance for helping students see these connections. The activity planning documents within the lessons include discussion prompts if it is the first time students are introduced to the topics or are building toward proficiency. For example, the activity planning document for Unit 2, Lesson 5, Activity 22, Hands-On Investigation: Rebound! includes discussion prompts at three levels of proficiency related to how energy changes form and transfers through a system, but misses the opportunity for students to build upon and make connections to knowledge and use of the dimensions in the other connected units.

  • In Grade 6, Unit 3: Air Conditioner, the materials do not demonstrate how the dimensions connect from unit to unit. The overview documents in the teacher materials list connections to Units 1 and 2; however, explicit connections to DCIs in the other units are not included and these documents provide no guidance for helping students see these connections. For example, the activity planning document for Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 13: Kinesthetic Models of Energy Transfer to and from the Refrigerant includes discussion prompts at three levels of proficiency related to tracking energy flows through a system, but misses the opportunity for students to build upon and make connections to knowledge and use of the dimensions in the other two units.

  • In Grade 7, Unit 6: Hindenburg Explosion, the materials do not demonstrate how the dimensions connect from unit to unit. The overview documents in the teacher materials list connections to Units 2 and 7; however, explicit connections to DCIs in the other units are not included and these documents provide no guidance for helping students see these connections. For example, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Hands-On Investigation: Mass Mix-Up includes suggestions for discussion prompts at three levels of proficiency related to energy and matter, but misses the opportunity for students to build upon and make connections to knowledge and use of the dimensions in the other two units.

  • In Grade 8, Unit 12: Albino Squirrels, the materials do not demonstrate how the dimensions connect from unit to unit. Students focus on the life science disciplinary core idea elements related to growth and development of organisms, inheritance of traits, variation of traits, and natural selection. In following an integrated pathway with the materials, the unit progression leads to Unit 13: Mystery Fossil and Unit 14: Hawaiian Flies. The DCI elements for Unit 13 are related to evidence of common ancestry and diversity, and those of Unit 14 focus on growth and development of organisms, natural selection, and adaptation. There are missed opportunities for the materials to support students in making connections between these core ideas as students progress from one unit to the next. Students are not presented with opportunities to build upon and make connections to knowledge and use of the dimensions in either of these two units.

Indicator 2a.ii

1 / 2

Materials have an intentional sequence where student tasks increase in sophistication.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they have an intentional sequence where student tasks increase in sophistication. While the materials are designed as a modular program meant to provide flexibility for districts to sequence the units to best meet district needs, two recommended sequences are provided in the Program Guide: an integrated pathway and a domain-specific pathway. The materials provide additional guidance on what to consider if designing a sequence of units that differs from the recommended sequences. 

Student tasks related to explaining phenomena and solving problems do not increase in sophistication across the series. While students generally build upon their learning throughout a unit as they work to understand and explain the anchoring phenomenon, the tasks related to explaining phenomena or solving problems do not increase in sophistication across the series.

Example where student tasks related to explaining phenomena or solving problems increases in sophistication within a single unit:

  • In Grade 8, Unit 12: Albino Squirrels, students explore the phenomenon of albino squirrels found in Olney, IL. Students develop an increasing complexity of understanding over the course of the unit. The phenomenon is introduced in Lesson 1 through images, texts, and videos. Students then develop an initial model and explanation for this phenomenon. In Lesson 2, students explore the genetic cause of albinism through the use of simulations and readings about the role of protein structure and melanin. In Lesson 3, they build upon their initial learning about protein structures as they investigate the genetic role of mutations and how these affect protein structures that result in a change in physical appearance. With the lens of asexual and sexual reproduction, Lesson 4 focuses on patterns of inheritance and variation of traits between parents and offspring. The materials present readings and explorations of gene maps and images of organisms in the same species to identify physical changes. Students analyze data, obtain and evaluate information, and develop a model to describe variation of traits. In Lesson 5, students explore the inheritance of traits, using statistics and Punnett squares. As the Olney squirrels are considered a town treasure, and thus, taken care of, students investigate the role of artificial selection as they apply their understanding of sexual reproduction and statistical genetics to explain why there are a large number of albino squirrels in Olney. After each lesson, students continue to build upon their model and explanation of the phenomenon.

Examples where student tasks related to explaining phenomena or solving problems do not increase in sophistication across multiple units or grades:

  • In the suggested sequence of units, Grade 6, Unit 3: Air Conditioner precedes Grade 7, Unit 9: Superstorm of 1993. In Unit 3, students learn about matter changing states. During Unit 9, students use their knowledge of changes of state to understand the water cycle and explain why different parts of the country experienced different kinds of precipitation from the same storm system. While students discuss change of state in a different context, the sophistication or complexity of how they model this concept does not increase. For example, in the third lesson of Unit 3, students investigate the role of thermal energy on the rate of change of state between liquid and gaseous forms. They also demonstrate their understanding by developing a model of the water system at the molecular level. In subsequent activities within the unit, students use a simulation to explore the effect of thermal energy transfer in the formation of a solid. Within the lessons in Unit 9, students again use their understanding of the role of energy transfer in the movement of water through Earth’s systems, including the processes of melting, precipitation, evaporation, and transpiration. Students develop a model of water movement through Earth’s spheres; however, student models do not require the inclusion of the role of energy driving this movement. This is a missed opportunity for increasing sophistication of understanding as students progress from Unit 3 to Unit 9 and across the series.

  • In the suggested sequence of units, Grade 7, Unit 8: Zebra Survival precedes Grade 8, Unit 16: Dead Fish in the Delta. Students connect their understanding of the dependence of organisms on their environment and natural disruptions to the ecosystem learned in Unit 8 to the effects of humans on organisms and their ecosystems in Unit 16. In Unit 8, students explore possible reasons for the decline in population of Grevy’s Zebra. They investigate how organisms in the savanna interact with one another and through data sets and images, explore the impact of disruptions to resource availability on population size on the savanna. Students use these understandings to develop a model that shows the interactions of different species and resource availability on zebra populations. In Unit 16, students engage in activities to explain a large fish kill in the Mississippi Delta. Throughout this unit, students explore the effect of nutrients from agricultural practices on resource availability, as well as the effect of transportation of goods on the development of the dead zone. Students end the unit by constructing an explanation for the dead fish found in the Mississippi Delta; this explanation is similar in complexity to the model developed in Unit 8. This is a missed opportunity for student tasks to increase with sophistication across the series.

Indicator 2b

2 / 2

Materials present Disciplinary Core Ideas (DCIs), Science and Engineering Practices (SEPs), and Crosscutting Concepts (CCCs) in a way that is scientifically accurate.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they present disciplinary core ideas (DCIs), science and engineering practices (SEPs), and crosscutting concepts (CCCs) in a way that is scientifically accurate. Across the grades, the teacher materials, student materials, and assessments accurately represent the three dimensions and are free from scientific inaccuracies.

Indicator 2c

2 / 2

Materials do not inappropriately include scientific content and ideas outside of the grade-band Disciplinary Core Ideas.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they do not inappropriately include scientific content and ideas outside of the grade-band disciplinary core ideas (DCIs). Materials contain no instances where non-scientific content or ideas are included as science ideas, no instances where scientific content or ideas are included without meaningful connections to grade-band DCIs, and no instances where DCIs from above or below the grade band are included without meaningful connections made to the grade-band DCIs.

Indicator 2d

Narrative Only

Materials incorporate all grade-band Disciplinary Core Ideas.

Indicator 2d.i

4 / 4

Physical Sciences

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate all grade-band disciplinary core ideas for physical science. Across the series, materials incorporate all grade-band components and all the associated elements of the physical science DCIs; one element is partially addressed. For a given DCI, all elements are typically included within the same unit and approached with a variety of activities. Most of the physical science DCIs are incorporated within the five physical science units: three are found in Grade 6, one in Grade 7, and one in Grade 8; one physical science DCI is addressed in a Grade 7 life science unit on life’s chemical processes.  

Examples of grade-band physical science DCI elements present in the materials:

  • PS1.A-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 6: Lesson 2: Exploring the Burning of Hydrogen, students observe the flammability of gases via video and document the characteristic properties of hydrogen, helium, and air. In another activity, they observe tealights and glass jars to find what happens to the flame when the tealights are covered in order to learn what causes a substance to burn. During the lesson’s last activity, students use the properties of common gases to determine what kind of gas is found in different test tubes by using evidence from the investigation and information on the properties of common gases. Students also apply their learning about the characteristic properties of hydrogen to explain the cause of the Hindenburg explosion and propose what may have stopped it from burning.

  • PS1.A-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 2, Activity 2: Where Does the Water Come From?, students record observations, list questions, and gather information through reading, discussing, and looking at pictures. Students then construct an explanation for the formation of water droplets on the outside of a glass of ice water by temperature differences to the different states of matter and the movement of molecules within each state.

  • PS1.A-M4. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 9: Icy Conditions, students construct an explanation for how ice forms on air conditioner coils that uses the concepts of molecular movement, states of matter, and energy flow. They describe how the "warm air blowing over the coils transfers heat to the cold coils. As a result, the water molecules in the air lose energy and slow down to form water droplets on the coils.” The liquid water would then transfer energy to a colder surface or substance in order for the ice to form.

  • PS1.A-M5. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 4, Activity 12: Starting a Reaction, students conduct an investigation about steel wool and rust and answer questions to explain the different structures of the molecules in gases and solids. Students are given a diagram of subunits of iron oxide (three oxygen atoms and two iron atoms) and then given a larger version of the diagram from which they select eight subunits. 

  • PS1.A-M6. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 11: How Temperature, Pressure, and Volume are Related, students watch the teacher demonstrate covering a bottle with a balloon and placing it in a tub of hot water causing the balloon to inflate, then moving the bottle into a tub of cold water and watching the balloon deflate. Students record their observations and discuss their answers. Then, students create a model of the inside of the bottle before heating, after heating, and after cooling to show the relationships between temperature, pressure, and volume, including the movement of molecules.

  • PS1.B-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 2, Activity 6: Hands-On Investigation: Electrolysis, students analyze the gases found in the two test tubes following the running of electrolysis, a chemical reaction. By applying an understanding that new substances are created from a chemical reaction, they use the characteristics of gases to determine what new substances are in each test tube.

  • PS1.B-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Candy Chemical Reactions, students use models to explain what happens to molecules in different chemical reactions. For example, along with the image of a burning candle, the materials present two representations of the chemical reaction: paraffin wax + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water and 2C16H34 +49O2 → 32CO2 + 34H2O. Students then list the number of molecules before and after the reaction for paraffin, oxygen, carbon dioxide, and water and list the number of atoms for carbon, hydrogen and oxygen.

  • PS1.B-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 4, Activity 12: Starting a Reaction, students conduct an investigation about steel wool and rust, and then predict and explain, "Does metal rusting require energy, or does it release energy like the Hindenburg explosion?" They are also given a set of procedures and asked to rewrite them to include steps for collecting data on energy changes. At the end of the activity, students summarize what they figured out about energy and matter.

  • PS2.A-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 4, Activity 10: Two Colliding Cars, students explain how a collision seen in a video demonstrates Newton’s third law of motion and create a model of what happens in the video: they demonstrate that the pair of interacting objects exert forces of equal strength on each other but in the opposite direction. 

  • PS2.A-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Hands-On Investigation: Interacting Forces, students investigate a spring-loaded cart, identify the component of the system and interaction of forces, and demonstrate that the motion of the cart is determined by the sum of the forces acting on the cart.

  • PS2.A-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 2, Activity 7: Hands-On Activity: Designing a Balloon-Powered Car, students test the effect of mass on the balloon-powered car and write a concluding statement that explains the greater the mass of the object, the greater the force needed to achieve the same change in motion. 

  • PS2.A-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 3, Activity 3: Fire Extinguisher Go-Kart, students make a model of the fire extinguisher go-kart system to establish a frame of reference and demonstrate the position and direction of forces and motions being described within that frame of reference.

  • PS2.B-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Hands-On Investigation: Push and Pull, students conduct an investigation with magnets and iron filings to gather data on magnetic fields and determine the strength and direction of magnetic forces.  

  • PS2.B-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 4, Activity 17: Hands-On Investigation: Sticky-Tape Lab, students plan and conduct an investigation into electrical forces using tape and compare their findings with that of magnetic forces.

  • PS2.B-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Gravity at Different Scales, students explore gravitational force and the role of scale on its strength. After investigating dropped objects and the role of air on the falling objects, students read historical accounts of the “discovery” of gravity for very large and very small objects. Students are then asked to "describe the scale at which gravity is acting on the levitating-orb system” and to “compare the gravitational forces exerted by Earth, the orb, and the pipe."

  • PS2.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 2, Activity 6: Hands-On Investigation: Gravity, Force, and Mass, students simulate earth’s gravitational force by investigating the relationship between force (measured with a spring scale) and mass to determine if gravity exerts an equal amount of force on all objects. Using the results, they predict what would happen if the same experiment was conducted on the moon and consider what would be the relationship between the force and objects with different masses.

  • PS2.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Hands-On Investigation: Push and Pull, students conduct an investigation with magnets and iron filings to gather data on magnetic fields and determine the strength and direction of magnetic forces.

  • PS2.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 4, Activity 16: What Causes Charge?, students investigate electrical fields by observing and recording the behavior of charged balloons.  

  • PS3.A-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 4, Activity 10: Two Colliding Cars, students read data and create graphs in order to explain which factors have the greatest effect on kinetic energy and demonstrate that motion energy is proportional to the mass of the moving object and grows with the square of its speed.

  • PS3.A-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 5, Activity 21: Energy Transfer, students observe two systems, a junkyard magnet, and a stretched rubber band, and compare the potential energy in each.

  • PS3.A-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 2, Activity 2: Where Does the Water Come From?, students observe water forming on the outside of a glass of ice water and then gather information about the difference between heat and thermal energy. Through reading text and discussions, they determine how thermal energy and its relation to molecular movement can help explain how water droplets formed on the outside of the cup. 

  • PS3.A-M4. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 5, Activity 18: Heating Curve Segments, students analyze a heating curve to determine where the changes of state are occurring. After a discussion, they show how matter and energy are related in each curve segment and describe the decrease of potential and kinetic energy in relation to the states of matter. 

  • PS3.B-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 1, Activity 2: Before and After Videos, students create a model of a rocket sled collision showing the parts of the system before, during, and after the collision in order to demonstrate that when the motion energy of an object changes, there is change in energy at the same time.

  • PS3.B-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 12: How an AC Cools Part 2, students evaluate different subsystems of the air conditioner system by noting within each system the transfer and direction of energy flow; what happens to the pressure, temperature, thermal energy, and state of matter of the various substances involved; and what happens to the molecules that make up the substances in terms of motion, state, kinetic energy, and potential energy. Keeping in mind the energy transfer, temperature, and substances involved, students share and discuss their theories about how the problem of ice formation on the air conditioner is likely happening.

  • PS3.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students are presented with the problem of ice forming on the interior side of windows. Applying knowledge of heat transfer and changes of state, students form ideas for why the ice is forming and, with pairs or in small groups, explain possible solutions. In their explanations and proposals, students specifically identify how heat transfers out of hotter regions or objects into colder one, in order to provide a possible solution to keep ice from forming on the air conditioner.

  • PS3.C-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 6, Activity 23: Levitating-Orb Reboot, students apply the relationship between force and energy transfer to the phenomenon of the levitating orb and identify the subsystems which interact with one another that result in the levitating orb. They then construct an explanation to include the cause and effect relationship between the type of force applied and the kind of energy that is transferred.

  • PS3.D-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 2, Activity 8: Hands-on Investigation: Making Food, students read about photosynthesis and refine a previously created model of two kelp forests to include the process of photosynthesis and thereby demonstrate the chemical reaction where plants produce sugars from sunlight and release oxygen.

  • PS3.D-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Potato Time-Lapse, students explain that a sprouting potato decreases in size as the sprouts from the potato increase due to the molecules of starch rearranging back to sugar so the plant can grow. Their explanation demonstrates that chemical reactions in plants release stored energy used for plant growth. Student explanations do not discuss this reaction in relation to oxygen and the production of carbon dioxide and other materials.

  • PS3.D-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 3, Activity 12: Releasing Energy, students read about cellular respiration then describe how energy is released by living things and add this understanding to clarify cellular respiration.

  • PS4.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 3: Modeling Sounds, students begin with correlating the vibrations caused by sound with the wave motion of a spring. In the next activity, they quantify the wave movement of a spring toy and describe two ways they can change the motion of the spring and what parts of the wave changes when the spring is moved a farther distance up and down. In a subsequent activity, they complete sentence starters describing the wave if the music is louder and faster and has lower pitch.

  • PS4.A-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 4, Activity 13: How Sound Travels, students observe a video of a tuning fork in water and discuss how sound is transmitted through both water and air. Citing their evidence gathered on energy transfer via particle movement, they then construct an explanation of how sound waves are transferred through matter.

  • PS4.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 5, Activity 18: Hands-on Investigation: The Properties of Light, students conduct an investigation with a light, prism, and colored filters. Students are asked to explain what happens to different colors of light when a white beam of light shines on red paper, what evidence supports that it is possible for a material to let some colors of light through but not others, and propose an explanation for how lights of different colors differ.

  • PS4.B-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Interactions of Light and Matter, students conduct an investigation about the behavior of light waves and gather data on how it interacts with other materials. They complete a graphic organizer where they provide examples from the lab to match vocabulary terms of light behavior (propagation, reflection, etc.). Students are asked to review their data table and evaluate similarities and differences in how light behaves when it interacts with the various test materials and identify patterns in the behavior of the light.

  • PS4.B-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 5: Wireless Signal, Activities 17-18, students investigate how light interacts with different materials. Students record observations and use their data to determine whether each material reflects, refracts, or absorbs light. Students answer questions about different behaviors of light, providing examples from their investigation. Students use color filters to observe that white light is a mixture of different colors and analyze how a prism breaks up white light as a result of different frequencies (colors) being bent varying amounts by the prism. Students conclude that the color of light seen depends on the frequency of the light wave,  and that the brightness of the light depends on the amplitude of the light wave.

  • PS4.B-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Cell Phone in a Vacuum, students watch a video of a cell phone in a vacuum showing that the phone does not make any sound but the display lights up. They make a claim and use evidence to explain if the wireless signal between the cell phones travels through a vacuum. The materials also include the following prompts: "Can the wireless signal between the cell phones travel through a vacuum?" and "Is it possible that the wireless signal between the cell phones travels as sound waves?” Through answering, students determine that light travels through space but cannot be a matter wave. 

  • PS4.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Signals in the System, students use models to simulate the transmission of analog signals and explain how they become distorted during transmission and that digital signals are more reliable. To simulate passing analog signals, one student copies a wave of music on a blank sheet of paper. This drawing is passed to a second student who draws a copy of the first student's drawing, this is repeated with a third student copying the drawing of the second student. The students then compare the final drawing to the original. To simulate converting an analog signal to digital, graph paper is used. A comparison is made with these drawings.

Example of a grade-band physical science DCI element that is partially present in the materials:

  • PS1.A-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 3, Activity 7: Modeling Molecules, students create models of different molecules, analyze their models, and draw conclusions about how atoms combine in different ways and amounts to form different molecules or substances. The activity does not address the understanding that molecules range in size from two to thousands of atoms.

Indicator 2d.ii

2 / 4

Life Sciences

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate all grade-band disciplinary core ideas for life sciences. Across the series, materials incorporate all but one grade-band elements of the life science DCIs. The materials do not incorporate the element LS1.B-M3 and partially address three elements; two of the three partially addressed elements are the only element associated with the DCI component (LS1.D and LS2.B). For a given DCI, all elements are typically included within the same unit and approached with a variety of activities. Life science DCIs are incorporated within the six life science units: one unit is found in Grade 6, two in Grade 7, and three in Grade 8.

Examples of grade-band life science DCI elements present in the materials:

  • LS1.A-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Under the Microscope, students observe slides of cells from a variety of living organisms. Students then read additional text and answer prompts around the concept of cells: living things are made of cells which come in different shapes and sizes, and organisms can be multicellular or unicellular. Before applying their learning of cells to explain how a cut heals, students construct an explanation about what features all living organisms have in common.

  • LS1.A-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Growing Cells, students analyze graphs of cell culture data related to cell growth and quantities of oxygen and carbon dioxide over time. They answer questions about the relationship between the amount of the two gases and the relationship between the gases and cell growth. Students select a claim, out of four that are provided, that best supports the evidence for the relationship between oxygen and carbon dioxide and cell growth. Using their analysis of the graphs and information from previous activities on the cell membrane model and mitochondria, students draw a cell structure model that shows the flow of sugar, oxygen, carbon dioxide, and energy, and explain how cell structures function to keep cells alive. 

  • LS1.A-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Fuel for Healing, students evaluate information that they learn about the circulatory and respiratory systems and how the systems work together to move blood and gases through cells. They review their claim about how mitochondria create energy. While reading a passage on organ systems, they highlight evidence that will strengthen their claims about where cells get energy for growth. Students write a claim explaining how the circulatory, respiratory, and digestive systems are involved in the healing process, and then come to a group consensus on an explanation about how cells, tissues, and body systems help heal a cut.

  • LS1.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Expression of Alleles, students analyze population data for traits in fruit flies and then use Punnett squares to model inheritance of fur color in squirrels.

  • LS1.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 4, Activity 11: Starfish Reproduction, students read a passage and discuss asexual reproduction in starfish. They apply the information they learn to explain how they know that squirrels reproduce sexually. 

  • LS1.B-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Fruit Fly Behaviors, students read text and watch videos to gather evidence that supports the claim that certain traits and behaviors help fruit flies survive and reproduce and to demonstrate that animals engage in characteristic behaviors that increase the odds of reproduction. The fruit fly traits and behaviors include tapping another fruit fly with its legs, following a nearby fruit fly closely, and beating its wings rapidly without flying.

  • LS1.B-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 5, Activity 11: The Koa Tree and the Kauaʻi Fruit Fly, students analyze maps and data of the Koa Forest, look at koa tree growth data in relation to the common native moth outbreaks, and read text about factors that affect plant growth. After group discussions, students answer prompts about plant growth and make recommendations for koa tree growth which demonstrates that genetic factors (seeds) and local conditions affect the healthy growth of plants.

  • LS1.C-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Potato Time-Lapse, students explain that a sprouting potato decreases in size as the sprouts from the potato increase due to the molecules of starch rearranging back to sugar for plant growth. This demonstrates that chemical reactions in plants release stored energy that is used for plant growth. Students are also asked to describe how this [potato growth] is similar to what is happening to kelp growing in Alaska.

  • LS1.D-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 6: To the Brain and Back, students investigate how skin cells detect pressure (sensory information). Students then answer questions to match other sense organs with the type of stimulus they detect. Students compare response time when catching a falling meter stick following a visual cue compared to an auditory cue. Students learn that a memory is formed when information is stored in the brain, then compare how different stimuli result in immediate responses or are stored as memories.

  • LS2.A-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 3, Activity 11: The Zebra Survival Game - Part 2: Predation, students explore the dependent interactions between living and nonliving things in an ecosystem and use a kinesthetic simulation to explore the effect of resources (nonliving), predation (living), and population (living) on the overall population of zebras.

  • LS2.A-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 2, Activity 5: The Zebra Survival Game - Part 1: Resource Availability, students explore the competition for limited resources on population growth. Students use a kinesthetic simulation to explore the effect of food, water and shelter (limited resources) on a change in population size.

  • LS2.A-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 2, Activity 9: Rainfall and Migration Patterns, students explore the effect of limited access to resources on population growth.  Students analyze seasonal rainfall and travel data for Burchell’s zebra over a one-year period to explain the migration pattern seen during specific months of the year.

  • LS2.A-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 3, Activity 15: How Organisms Interact in Ecosystems, students explore the predatory, competitive, and mutually beneficial relationships within an ecosystem. After investigating the effects of predation and limited resources on population size, students read text about the relationship types found in an ecosystem. Students complete a graphic organizer to synthesize information in the reading and complete a fill-in-the-blank paragraph which describes the interactions on the savanna.

  • LS2.A-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 5, Activity 10: Kauaʻi Fruit Fly, students investigate a relationship between the Kauaʻi Fruit Fly and the Koa tree in order to understand how the destruction of trees results in the decline of the fruit fly population.  Students analyze various data sets in order to identify the interdependent relationship between the two species that results in the need to explore tree restoration.

  • LS2.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 8, Lesson 4, Activity 16: The Zebra Survival Game - Part 3: Natural Disruptions, students explore the effect of ecosystem disruptions on a population. Using data from other lessons, students predict the effect of a natural disruption on the zebra population. They use a kinesthetic simulation to explore the effect of a natural disturbance on an ecosystem.

  • LS2.C-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 8, Lesson 5, Activity 22: What is Biodiversity?, students explore the role of biodiversity on ecosystem health. They observe images of different ecosystems and record their findings. Using information from a video describing biodiversity, students rank the ecosystems from most to least biodiverse, with a rationale for each ranking. Lastly, they provide an explanation as to the benefits of monitoring ecosystem biodiversity.

  • LS3.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Modeling Squirrel Offspring, students engage in an activity to model the inheritance of traits in squirrels. They compare similarities and differences, leading to definitions for chromosomes, genes, and traits. Students use their evidence to refine explanations for albinism in squirrels.

  • LS3.A-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 1, Activity 3: What’s Going On, having made observations of albino and gray squirrels, students develop initial models to describe the causes of differences in squirrel fur color and eye color. Using their models as a guide, they construct explanations to describe the causes of the different traits in the albino squirrels and the gray squirrels. Individual models are shared and group consensus models developed. Students participate in a gallery walk to observe and compare models, as well as record additional questions they have as a result of observing the different models. Students summarize what they have figured out about traits and how they are inherited as a result of the activity. 

  • LS3.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 4, Activity 10: Comparing Chromosomes, students observe images of a starfish, its offspring, and three chromosome pairs alongside images of fruit fly parents and their offspring. After they record observations for both sets of images, they discuss observations to develop a group consensus about how the chromosomes of the fruit fly parents and offspring might look. They analyze a fruit fly gene map, record observations, and write questions about how they think starfish and fruit flies pass genetic information from parent to offspring in a graphic organizer. 

  • LS3.B-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 3, Activity 8: The Eyes Do Not Have It, students observe two images of fruit flies with different wing, body, and eye traits and complete a Venn diagram to compare and contrast the flies. They observe two additional images that show fruit fly mutations of short wings and dark colored bodies and predict how each mutation might affect the organism. Students analyze data on the survival of fruit flies related to each type of mutation observed and describe patterns in the data regarding the effects of the two mutations. They apply their reasoning to traits associated with Olney’s albino squirrels and how the albinism trait affects the squirrels’ survival. After analyzing observations with respect to expected types of genes and chromosomes present in the flies, students write a scientific explanation, with claim-evidence-reasoning, to refine initial explanations for albinism in the squirrels in Olney.   

  • LS4.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 2: Rock Story, students explore how fossils provide a window into earth’s past and determine their age. In Activity 3, students investigate relative dating techniques and diversity of past lifeforms by placing known fossils in appropriate rock layers. They determine relative ages of the fossils using the Law of Superposition. In Activity 4, students use readings and graphical analysis to explore absolute-dating techniques. In Activity 5, students use patterns in the rock strata in order to describe how diversity of life changed over time. 

  • LS4.A-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Evolutionary Tree, students compare anatomical features in fossils to determine evolutionary descent. They develop an evolutionary tree of the chordates using known characteristics. Using this model, they predict where on this tree their mystery fossil is most likely to fall.

  • LS4.A-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Embryologic Development, students explore the role of embryological development in determining common ancestry. They read about and compare images of the role of embryological development in chordates. They compare the stages of development and respond to multiple select questions in which they identify conclusions that support their analysis of patterns and observations of evolutionary relationships.

  • LS4.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 3, Activity 6: Hands-On Investigation: Trait Variations, students describe why having specific traits is desirable and why variations in traits could be unfavorable and advantageous. Their explanations demonstrate that natural selection leads to the predominance of certain traits and the suppression of others.

  • LS4.B-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 6, Activity 18: Results of Dog Breeding, students read a passage and watch a video on dog breeding that address artificial selection and inbreeding. They construct explanations for the occurrence of genetic diseases in dogs which includes how parental traits are passed to offspring.

  • LS4.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 6, Activity 12, Unit Project: The Next Generation, students create a population change model for three generations. Using the model and data table, they explain how a species might adapt, form a new species, or go extinct. The explanation demonstrates adaptation by natural selection acting over generations, traits that support successful survival and reproduction, and the change in distribution of traits in a population.

  • LS4.D-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 5, Activity 25: Ecosystem Services, students explore how changes in biodiversity can affect humans’ resources and ecosystem services. Students read text about human reliance on biodiversity and ecosystem services, complete a graphic organizer based upon that reading, and predict the effect of changes in biodiversity on ecosystem services.

Examples of grade-band life science DCI elements partially present in the materials:

  • LS1.C-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 2, Activity 8: Hands-On Investigation: Making Food, students read about photosynthesis and refine a previously created model of two kelp forests by including the process of photosynthesis and demonstrating the chemical reaction where plants produce sugars from sunlight and oxygen is released. The content focuses on plants only and does not include information on microorganisms.

  • LS2.B-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 4, Activity 15: Herbivores and Decomposers in the Kelp Forest, students use information obtained from videos, text, and data tables to refine their kelp forest models to include organisms found at each trophic level in a kelp forest and how they get food. They also explain where energy and matter are coming from and going, how matter can be transferred in the ecosystem demonstrating food webs, and how matter and energy are transferred within this aquatic ecosystem. The materials do not address how atoms that make up living organisms cycle between the living and nonliving parts of ecosystems.

Grade-band life science DCI element not present in the materials:

  • LS1.B-M3. Plants reproduce in a variety of ways, sometimes depending on animal behavior and specialized features for reproduction.

Indicator 2d.iii

4 / 4

Earth and Space Sciences

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate all grade-band disciplinary core ideas (DCIs) for earth and space sciences. Across the series, materials incorporate all grade-band components and the associated elements of the earth and space science DCIs; however, two elements (ESS3.A-M1 and ESS3.C-M1) are partially addressed. For a given DCI, all elements are typically included within the same unit and approached with a variety of activities. All earth and space science DCIs are incorporated within the five earth and space science units: one unit is found in Grade 6, two in Grade 7, and two in Grade 8. 

Examples of grade-band earth and space science DCI elements present in the materials:

  • ESS1.A-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 3, Activity 5: Patterns in Shadows of the Red Moon, students revisit their physical model of the sun-earth-moon system from the previous activity to replicate the observable shadows as shown in the lunar eclipse video. They plan and use their model to collect data. Lastly, they draw a revised model using new information to explain the shadow patterns observed. 

  • ESS1.A-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Closer Look at Planetary Objects, students view an image of Jupiter and compare it to previous observations. They conduct additional research about a planetary object including images and data obtained from technology tools. They record properties of the object researched and cite sources of evidence. After sharing their research, they read about the Milky Way galaxy being one galaxy in the estimated two trillion galaxies in the observable universe and watch a video on how the Hubble Telescope works to uncover other galaxies. Lastly, they explain how their models help explain the shape of the Milky Way.

  • ESS1.B-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 5, Objects in the Night Sky, students observe a teacher demonstration that models motion in space with different sized marbles moving around a circular stretched fabric background. They also watch two videos, "Gravity and Speed" and "Gravity and Orbits" to broaden their learning. In the next lessons, students discuss their knowledge of the planets, planet properties, and how planets move in space. They apply their understanding of orbits from the previous activity to the following prompt: "Your Earth-sun-moon models in this unit have represented Earth orbiting around the sun as evidence for the patterns in moon phases and lunar and solar eclipse observations. The mass of the sun is 333,000 times more than the mass of Earth. Based on your models and the additional planetary data, can you support the claim that the other planets are also orbiting around the sun?"

  • ESS1.B-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 4, Activity 7:The Disappearing Sun, students watch videos of both solar and lunar eclipses and then explain the causes of both and how they are similar and different. They include ideas about the causes of the shadows, the moon phases, the position and motions within the earth-moon-sun system, differences in colors, and how light from the sun interacts with the system.

  • ESS1.B-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 4, Activity 10: Modeling the Seasons in Alaska, students observe a teacher demonstration of the sun-earth model and the revolution of earth around the sun and collect data of how the intensity of light changes on the location on the globe. Students then fill in the blanks of a paragraph describing seasons and solar radiation.

  • ESS1.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 5, Activity 14: Other Objects in Space, students observe an image of the Milky Way galaxy and record their observations. They watch a video describing the formation of the solar system from the beginning of the solar nebula through the discussion of two possible theories as to what triggers the materials to clump together. They read a passage that describes the role of gravity in the formation of planets and then compare the formation of earth's moon to the formation of the solar system. After writing what questions they have, they reflect on the demonstration of the force of gravity on objects in space and use evidence from the video and passage to explain how the model represents the formation of planetary objects.

  • ESS1.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 7: Rock and Roll, students label layers of rock in order of relative age demonstrating that a geologic time scale interpreted from rock strata provides a way to organize earth’s history by relative age only.

  • ESS1.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 2, Activity 2: Colossal Fossil Jostle, students complete an interactive simulation that explores the chronological order of fossils in conjunction with the relative ages of rock layers. They construct an explanation about how the fossil record reveals earth’s history and how rock layers and organisms change over time.

  • ESS1.C-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Ocean Ridges, students explain the type of boundary interaction responsible for the formation of ocean ridges, demonstrating that tectonic processes continually generate new ocean seafloor at the ridges.

  • ESS2.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Hands-On Investigation: Plate Interactions, students use previous experience with energy transfer from convection and information about plate boundary interactions to explain the processes that occur at each type of boundary. The explanation demonstrates that earth’s processes are a result of energy flowing from matter cycling due to energy within earth’s hot interior producing physical changes in earth’s crust.

  • ESS2.A-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Cloud Energy, students explore the role of energy from heat, specifically the sun, and gravity in the movement of water within a system. After observing a teacher demonstration, students analyze data patterns between the amount of snow and temperatures in order to build their understanding of cloud formation. Applying this understanding of clouds, they describe how changes in energy drive water movement within storms, and add to their model to show the various impacts of the sun’s energy on the storm system.

  • ESS2.A-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 3, Activity 12: Releasing Energy, students explore the transfer of energy through the processes of photosynthesis and cellular respiration. After reading how energy, beginning with that from the sun, flows through these processes and analyzing the accompanying models, students construct an explanation to describe the flow of energy and the movement of matter within an organism.

  • ESS2.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Down in the Trenches, students read about the Puerto Rico Trench and Sonar Mapping. After discussing how Sonar Mapping could lead to scientists' creation of ocean floor mapping, students analyze images of ocean trenches and plate tectonics. They create a model of the "interaction of the Caribbean and North Atlantic Plates at the Puerto Rico Trench." This learning continues into Activity 10: Ocean Ridges when students explain the type of boundary interaction responsible for the formation of ocean ridges, demonstrating that tectonic processes continually generate new ocean seafloor at the ridges.

  • ESS2.A-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 4, Activity 12: Energy Data, students describe potential causes for stone arch formations including a timescale for formation to happen and explain how patterns of earthquakes at different scales of time and space relate to energy. This demonstrates the planet’s systems interacting over scales of time and how these interactions have shaped earth’s history and will determine its future.

  • ESS2.A-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 4, Activity 14: Puerto Rico Rocks, students explore the microscopic process of change in mechanical weathering to explain what caused the arch to form and the amount of time this process would take.

  • ESS2.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Continent Puzzle, students support the claim that continents were originally one large landmass selecting evidence provided in a video model of continental drift. Maps showing the apparent fit of present day continents lead to a discussion of Pangea and make clear how earth's plates have moved great distances, collided, and spread apart to result in the current location of continents.

  • ESS2.C-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 2: Rainstorms and Snowstorms, students explore the cycling of water through the spheres via evaporation, condensation, and precipitation. In Activity 2, students study cloud formation via demonstration and investigation. In Activity 4, they explore cycling of water through the spheres via crystallization. Through video and data sets, they also explore the relationship between temperature and precipitation types.

  • ESS2.C-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 3, Activity 6: The Water Cycle, students explore the cycling of water through the spheres and the role of downhill flows on land within that cycling. Students read an article about groundwater and how it comes to be and then develop a model of the water cycle showing the roles of evaporation, condensation, precipitation, and downhill flow on that cycling.

  • ESS2.C-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 4, Activity 7: Hands-On Investigation: Water and Plants, students explore the cycling of water through the spheres via transpiration and investigate the role of vegetation density and temperature change on precipitation amounts.

  • ESS2.C-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 6, Activity 12: Predicting the Superstorm, students explore the use of probability for weather forecasting. They read a passage describing how meteorologists used models to predict the superstorm and describe a time when forecasting was different than what was experienced. Lastly, students develop a weather prediction for a given location where they use various maps to analyze how the location, (i.e, landforms, distance to oceans) along with the patterns of wind movements impact weather.

  • ESS2.C-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Cloud, students explore the role of energy from heat, specifically the sun, and gravity in the movement of water within the system. After observing a teacher demonstration, students analyze data patterns between the amount of snow and temperatures in order to build their understanding of cloud formation. Applying this understanding of clouds, they describe how changes in energy drive water movement within storms, and add to their model to show the various impacts of the sun’s energy on the storm system.

  • ESS2.C-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 5, Activity 12: Observing Ocean Currents, students watch a video that shows the different temperatures in water creating convection currents. After watching the demonstration, students draw what they saw and explain why they think it happened. This activity specifically focuses on temperature differences driving currents.

  • ESS2.C-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 5, Activity 13: Modeling Ocean Currents, students conduct an investigation to explore salinity and ocean currents. Using this knowledge, along with the previous activity which explores temperature and ocean currents, students use their models to answer questions about impacts of the ocean, specifically in relation to Alaska. Students then review diagrams of the ocean conveyor belt and summarize their understandings of ocean currents.

  • ESS2.C-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 4, Activity 16: Agents of Change, students describe factors that helped shape natural arches on the coastline of Puerto Rico, demonstrating that water’s movements cause weathering and erosion and change the land’s surface features. 

  • ESS2.C-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 4, Activity 15: Cave Formation, students discuss how they think the arches were formed and examine images of caves in Puerto Rico. Taking what they know about formations on the surface of earth, they investigate and explain how caves could have formed underground. After completing an investigation to show how saltwater forms on strings connecting two beakers of water, students examine structures found in caves and talk about how rainwater can impact the formations underground.

  • ESS2.D-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 4, Activity 11: Hands-On Investigation: Changing Temperatures and Distance from the Sea, students complete an investigation  modeling how sunlight changes the temperature of different substances. In conclusion, students are given the scenario of three different cities - one surrounded by dark-colored, rocky surfaces, another by light-colored surfaces, and a third on the edge of a lake. Students select and justify which city would likely have the highest summer air temperature and why. They also select and justify which would have the warmest average winter temperature and why.

  • ESS2.D-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 6, Activity 12: Predicting the Superstorm, students explore the use of probability for weather forecasting. They read a passage describing how meteorologists used models to predict the Superstorm and describe a time when the forecast was different from what they experienced. Then, students develop a prediction for a given location.

  • ESS2.D-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 5, Activity 13: Modeling Ocean Currents, students conduct an investigation to explore salinity and ocean currents. Using this knowledge with the previous activity which explores temperature and ocean currents, they use their models to answer questions about impacts of the ocean, specifically in relation to Alaska. Students then review diagrams of the ocean conveyor belt and summarize their understandings of ocean currents.

  • ESS3.B-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 6, Activity 14: Getting Ready for the Storm, students explore the history of natural hazards in order to predict future events. Students analyze maps of natural weather hazards and why people would want to know this information.

  • ESS3.B-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Natural Hazard Detection Systems, students select and justify a location for an earthquake-detection monitoring station based on evidence from a map, demonstrating that map information and understanding geologic forces can help forecast locations and future events.

  • ESS3.C-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 4, Activity 11: Farming and Population Growth, students analyze data on human population, crop size, and fertilizer to identify patterns. They use their information to explain the occurrence of the first documented dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico. Student learning is applied during the final project when they complete a design project to construct a solution that prevents the dead zone.

  • ESS3.D-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 7, Activity 17: Human Activity and Effects on Climate Change, students analyze two graphs: Trends in Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide (specifically noting the role of fossil fuels) and Global Yearly surface temperatures. They then construct an explanation as to how fossil fuels affect the atmosphere and temperatures. Using scientific and technical information from the graphs and reading passage, students construct an explanation about the role of humans in this relationship and update their model to show how this information could impact the Alaska dogsled race route.

Examples of grade-band earth and space science DCI elements partially present in the materials:

  • ESS3.A-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 5, Activity 13: Mississippi Barges, students obtain and communicate information on the watershed of the Mississippi, uneven distribution of resources upon which humans depend, and how they are transported by barges on the Mississippi River. They create an infographic to communicate what they learn about resource distribution and transportation of nonrenewable and renewable resources. They analyze and draw conclusions about the transport of resources along the Mississippi, the flow of water in and out of the watershed, and how these connect agriculture, mining, and fertilizer across the transport system. Whereas students read that sand and gravel were unevenly deposited 10,000 years ago by glaciers and that coal comes from ancient swamps over hundreds of millions of years old that only occurred in certain places, the materials do not specifically address the concept that past geologic processes caused the uneven distribution of these resources.

  • ESS3.C-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Nutrients and the Watershed, students read a passage about nutrients found in the Mississippi River watershed and analyze a map of the total nitrogen entering the system, a pie chart of sources of the nitrogen, and a map of atmospheric nitrogen. Then they develop a model of the Mississippi River Watershed system and use this learning to refine models of the dead fish in the Delta. Through refining their models, they deepen the explanation for how humans can impact the environment: in this case, the influx of nitrogen can cause dead zones in certain habitats. The materials do not address how changing the environment can have positive impacts for different living things.

Indicator 2d.iv

4 / 4

Engineering, Technology, and Applications of Science

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate all grade-band disciplinary core ideas (DCIs) for engineering, technology, and applications of science. Across the series, materials incorporate all grade-band components and associated elements of the engineering, technology, and applications of science (ETS) DCIs. All lessons with ETS elements fall at the end of the unit and serve as the culminating unit project. These may include multiple elements of the same DCI or more than one element across different ETS DCIs or components. 

The materials include ETS DCIs in four physical science units, one life science unit, and one earth and space science unit. Across the series, ETS DCIs are incorporated within three Grade 6 units, two Grade 7 units, and one Grade 8 unit.

Examples of grade-band engineering, technology, and applications of science (ETS) DCIs present in the materials:

  • ETS1.A-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students are presented with the problem of ice forming on the interior side of windows. They read about how engineers design solutions and specifically note criteria and constraints. After discussing as a class and reviewing their knowledge on heat transfer and changes of state, students create a list of criteria and constraints for solutions to the icy window problem. They brainstorm ideas for why the ice is forming and, with pairs or in small groups, brainstorm possible solutions to keep this from happening. Using various criteria and a Pugh matrix, students rate the possible solutions and construct an explanation for which solution they would propose based on their evaluations.

  • ETS1.B-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 5, Activity 12: Unit Project: Hands-On Engineering: Defining Design Problem, students use a balloon powered car developed in a previous lesson to perform in competition events. They determine the changes that need to be made to the car, applying scientific principles based on the event, and test designs before being implemented. They conduct several tests after each modification in order to determine the effectiveness of the changes before each event.

  • ETS1.B-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 6, Activity 29: Unit Project: Researching a Local Habitat, students explore a process for evaluating a solution to a problem by how well it meets given criteria and constraints. They read through a provided multi-species plan to identify how each feature is important to the success of the plan. 

  • ETS1.B-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 7, Activity 25: Unit Project: Hands-on Engineering: Applying Force, students develop a solution to a problem by utilizing parts of other solutions. They design two possible solutions to the given problem and are asked to compare with other teams. Then, students identify pros and cons of each solution to make adjustments as needed in order to meet the criteria.

  • ETS1.B-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 4, Activity 11: Burning the Fabric, students use questions about what could cause the burning of the Hindenburg from the previous lesson (hydrogen, fabric) and video data of fabric burning to create additional questions that need answering. The videos present three models that are burned: one covered with plain fabric, one covered with fabric painted with three coats of aluminum like the bottom of the Hindenburg, and the third fabric painted with iron oxide and aluminum like the upper half of the Hindenburg. Students collect data from these tests and then develop a claim and construct an explanation. Lastly, students explore multiple facets of what they have figured out from both the model of burning hydrogen and the model of burning fabric to help them think about what they still need to investigate.

  • ETS1.C-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students are presented with the problem of ice forming on the interior side of windows. After discussing as a class and reviewing their knowledge on heat transfer and changes of state, students brainstorm ideas for why the ice is forming and, with pairs or in small groups, brainstorm possible solutions to keep this from happening. Using various criteria, they rate the possible solutions and construct an explanation for which solution they would propose based on their evaluations.

  • ETS1.C-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 5, Activity 12: Unit Project: Hands-On Engineering: Defining Design Problem, students use the iterative process of testing the most promising solutions and modify what is proposed based on the test results. After modifying their balloon car, students engage in the iterative design process that would allow their balloon car to win a competitive event.

Indicator 2e

Narrative Only

Materials incorporate all grade-band Science and Engineering Practices.

Indicator 2e.i

1 / 2

Asking Questions and Defining Problems

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for asking questions and defining problems and all grade-band elements across the series. Seven of the eight elements are incorporated, of which three elements are partially addressed; one element (AQDP-M7) is not addressed. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to ask questions or define problems; students use elements of this SEP in each grade and across each science discipline. The element AQDP-M1 is the most commonly addressed element of this SEP across the series.

Examples of grade-band elements of Asking Questions and Defining Problems present in the materials:

  • AQDP-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 1, Activity 1: Earthquake in the News, students watch a video of an earthquake in Puerto Rico and then list questions they have after watching.

  • AQDP-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 5, Activity 22: What is Biodiversity, students observe and record what they wonder about various ecosystems and develop questions about biodiversity and the relationships between dependent and independent variables that influence the ecosystems. They do not ask questions about relationships within models.

  • AQDP-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 6, Activity 15: Unit Project: Using a Model, students refine their model to locations where it could be possible to prevent the fish kill in the Delta. Using these locations and their current model, students list potential causes for dying fish in the Delta and ask questions about at least one of the issues they noticed to focus them in on creating solutions to the problem in the following activity (i.e, "Can nutrients be removed from streams and rivers in the Mississippi River watershed?").

  • AQDP-M5. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Hands-On Investigation: What is in the Air?, students pose questions to clarify what happens to a candle flame when enclosed in a jar. Students are directed to ask questions to “clarify what happened to the candle flame.” Students use empirical evidence from the lesson to answer these questions.

  • AQDP-M8. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 6, Activity 16: Unit Project: Design Process, students reflect on their design project and list other questions they would need to answer to continue developing their design. They use those questions to create a design project to develop a solution to the dying fish in the Delta. In their design, students complete an engineering design sheet which requires them to define the problem, propose a solution, describe how they will evaluate the solution through criteria and constraints, and list all materials needed to construct and test their solution. Students present their ideas to classmates in a gallery walk and then, individually, explain how their design solution solves the problem of Dead Fish in the Delta. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Asking Questions and Defining Problems partially present in the materials:

  • AQDP-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 1, Activity 2: Olney’s Squirrels, students observe videos and images of the squirrels in Olney and then ask questions to identify and clarify evidence that would explain the cause of the albinism. There are missed opportunities for students to ask questions about the premise of an argument or claim. 

  • AQDP-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Candy Chemical Reactions, students record the number of molecules in reactants and products in various chemical equations, as demonstrated in physical models, and ask questions related to these relationships within the model. Students do not ask questions about relationships between dependent and independent variables.

  • AQDP-M6. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 3, Activity 6: What is Evaporation?, students list questions they have about evaporation and determine which of those questions could be investigated in the classroom. Although students determine if it would be possible to investigate questions within a classroom, there are missed opportunities to form a hypothesis about their questions. 

Grade-band element of Asking Questions and Defining Problems not present in the materials:

  • AQDP-M7. Ask questions that challenge the premise(s) of an argument or the interpretation of a data set.

Indicator 2e.ii

2 / 2

Developing and Using Models

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for developing and using models and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate all grade-band elements of this SEP across the series. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to develop and use models; students use elements of this SEP in each grade and across each science discipline, with the elements of MOD-M4 and MOD-M5 used most frequently.

Examples of grade-band elements of Developing and Using Models across the series present in the materials:

  • MOD-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 6, Activity 24: Modeling the Levitating Orb System, students use a rubric as a guide to evaluate their classmates’ models and provide them with meaningful feedback to revise models so that they represents the levitating-orb system more clearly or completely.

  • MOD-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 2, Activity 6: Hands-On Investigation: Electrolysis, students use observations from an investigation of electricity running through water to construct a flowchart model of electrolysis and include what happens when energy is added to the system.

  • MOD-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 5, Activity 16: Kelp and Sea Urchins, students use the model of a kelp forest ecosystem to explain data that is presented about the ecosystem. Then they revise their model to account for the population density presented in the data.

  • MOD-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 6: Setting Boundaries, students watch a video of a volcano erupting in Chile. Based on what they know about earthquakes, students construct an explanation about what could be causing this volcanic eruption that also notes plate movement at different types of boundaries and their effects. They create a model to support their explanation, and then watch and read about ocean trenches to further expand their models.

  • MOD-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Down in the Trenches, students read about ocean floors, specifically ocean mapping and trenches. They note patterns and compare maps of plate tectonics and ocean trenches. Using this information, students draw a model explaining the interaction of the Caribbean and North Atlantic Plates at the Puerto Rico Trench. 

  • MOD-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 13: Kinesthetic Models of Energy Transfer to and from the Refrigerant, students work in two groups where each is given a scenario to develop a model. The materials prompt one group to “develop a kinesthetic demonstration that illustrates any changes in state that occur as refrigerant cycles through an air conditioner and suddenly loses air flow over the coils. The model should show any changes in kinetic energy, thermal energy transfer, volume, and pressure as appropriate." The second group is to “develop a kinesthetic demonstration that illustrates any changes in state that occur as refrigerant leaks from the closed system. The model should show any changes in kinetic energy, thermal energy transfer, volume, and pressure as appropriate." With specific attention to their scenario, each group works together to create simulation models that explain their theories for what caused ice to form on the air conditioner.

  • MOD-M6. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Plate Interactions, students watch a video about the causes of plate movement. They complete an activity with graham crackers and frosting to model different types of tectonic boundaries and plate movement (divergent, transform, and collision plate boundaries). Students note what happens at these boundaries, and then analyze images to compare the unobservable mechanisms of plate boundary movement shown by their model to a 3-D map of the Atlantic Ocean and Caribbean sea. They then discuss how they know the Puerto Rico earthquake could not be the result of a transform boundary.

  • MOD-M7. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Continent Puzzle, students create a map of the world using cut out pieces of paper representing continents on which they draw land features studied in the previous activity. They move the continent pieces around to see if they fit together like a puzzle. Lastly, they read and watch a video about continental drift and write a claim about how the continents formed their current shapes and arrangements. 

  • MOD-M7. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 6, Activity 19: Hands-On Investigation: Nerve Response Speed, students investigate the nerve response speed to sound and sight stimuli. They use the results to develop a flowchart model showing receptor inputs (stimulus), the movement of information along nerve cells, and the resulting outputs (body response to stimulus).

Indicator 2e.iii

1 / 2

Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for planning and carrying out investigations and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate four of the five elements of this practice; one element (INV-M3) is not addressed. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to plan or carry out investigations; students use elements of this SEP in each grade and across each science discipline, most frequently using elements of this SEP in the physical science and earth science units. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Planning and Carrying Out Investigations across the series present in the materials:

  • INV-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 3, Activity 7: Variety of Variables, students work in small groups to design and conduct an investigation to explore factors that control the rate of evaporation. Students predict the factors that might affect evaporation, propose how to test the factors, decide how they will control variables, and note how they will record measuring molecular motion. They predict what will happen in their investigation and then, in pairs or small groups, conduct their investigation and record their data. This activity does not address individual planning of an investigation.

  • INV-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 6, Activity 15: Investigating for a TV Show, students use evidence from a reading and previous lessons to individually design a series of investigations in which they could collect data to help answer an earlier presented myth: “if the Hindenburg airship fabric was made of materials available with current technology, it would not have exploded.” When designing the investigations, students respond to prompts regarding physical properties, chemical structure, and thermal transfer and explain how they would test each material, what type of tools, equipment, and data collection they would use, and what their predicted outcomes are. Students also reflect on how they have grown in this unit, specifically in relation to providing evidence to support or refute an argument. This activity does address collaborative planning of an investigation.

  • INV-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 4, Activity 13: Landslides, students discuss the changes of landscape in Puerto Rico due to the earthquake. Students analyze an image of a damaged roadway and answer questions about the causes and amount of time this change could have taken. To further investigate, students test three different materials (soil, sand, and gravel) with three different variables (slope angle, shaking, and moisture level). If students have identified another possible cause for landscape changes, they may test this as well. They conduct their investigation noting patterns and any relation to the image from the beginning of the activity. This activity does not address revising of experimental design.

  • INV-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 5: Unit Project: Balloon-Powered Rocket Car Competition, students use the balloon car from Lesson 3 to perform a series of “balloon-powered car competition events.” Students choose two events in which to compete and may make changes to their cars as needed to perform the tasks (fastest car, farthest car, most accurate car, and/or most powerful car). After making changes and performing the tasks, they record results of how their car did with a focus on aspects of revisions to their design modifications made in relation to the car's performance in the activity. 

  • INV-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 5, Activity 10: Moving Superstorm, students collect data through reading, analyzing images, and conducting an investigation to answer questions about air masses. 

  • INV-M4. In Unit 1, Lesson 5, Activity 12: Hands-On Engineering: Defining the Design Problem, students modify a balloon-powered car previously developed to compete in two of four identified events. After a modification is made, students conduct tests to determine the effectiveness of the modification for the event. If the modification is not effective, students may continue to modify.

  • INV-M5. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 4, Activity 7: Hands-On Investigation: Water and Plants, students read about global rainfall patterns to explore the relationship between precipitation and vegetation density. They conduct an investigation to look at how a plant processes water when variables, such as temperature, change. To record data, students use a celery stalk and water system placed in various locations and conditions in the classroom: undisturbed at room temperature, six inches under a bright light, and in front of a fan with normal lighting. They analyze the results to decide if there is evidence for a claim about vegetation density and precipitation. 

Example of a grade-band element of planning and carrying out investigations missing from the materials:

  • INV-M3. Evaluate the accuracy of various methods for collecting data.

Indicator 2e.iv

1 / 2

Analyzing and Interpreting Data

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for analyzing and interpreting data and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate seven of the eight elements of this practice, of which two are partially addressed; one element (DATA-M8) is missing. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to analyze and interpret data; students use elements of this SEP in each grade and across each science discipline, commonly using multiple elements of this SEP in each unit. The element DATA-M4 is the most commonly addressed element of this SEP across the series.

Examples of grade-band elements of Analyzing and Interpreting Data present in the materials:

  • DATA-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 5, Activity 19: Natural Hazard Emergencies, students help the Office of Emergency Management (OEM) to create a preparedness plan to minimize the loss of life on the Puerto Rico coast from earthquakes and landslides. They analyze different data sets regarding earthquakes and tsunamis in Puerto Rico and create action steps for the preparedness plan. In this plan, students use data to decide if earthquake monitoring stations should collaborate with landslide-monitoring stations, volcano-monitoring stations, or both and how the deep water, narrow beaches, and dense housing relate to potential impacts from these disasters. In their proposed solutions, students suggest a plan that includes things such as where to place monitors, communication, and evacuation efforts.

  • DATA-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 2: Earthquake Data, students analyze a map of the aftershocks of the December 2019 earthquake in Puerto Rico. Noticing patterns, students answer questions and record learning in a graphic organizer. Noting similarities and differences, they examine maps of Puerto Rican and South American land features and analyze a map of earthquakes in Chile and earthquake activity across all continents. With this analysis, they provide evidence of the connection between patterns in earthquakes and land features.

  • DATA-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Expression of Alleles, students analyze data showing three different traits in a fruit fly population to determine the probability of the expression of a recessive allele. They also use a Punnett Square to model the probability of allele combinations resulting in albino or gray squirrels.

  • DATA-M6. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Breath and Beat, students conduct an investigation to determine the relationship between breathing rate and heart rate. Then they identify limitations of the data they collected and how they could improve its accuracy and reliability.

  • DATA-M7. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 5, Activity 11: Highs and Lows, students compare maps of the United States showing air pressure data over three days of the Superstorm. Students look for similarities and differences between these maps as they analyze the pressure systems and changes in air flow over the three days. Students use the changes in location of the air masses as evidence that the air masses moved during the storm.

Examples where materials partially address the practice of analyzing and interpreting data:  

  • DATA-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 2, Activity 6:The Zebra Survival Game - Part 1: Graphing Game Results, students graph data collected in the previous activity. They analyze the graphs and identify linear relationships in regard to population and resource availability. Students are not provided opportunities to work with large data sets nor nonlinear relationships.

  • DATA-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Rain and Snow in Storms, students analyze charts with data showing temperature and location and answer a question about the relationship between temperature and precipitation type: "The data from the Superstorm indicates that there may be a relationship between temperature and whether the precipitation for a location was rain or snow. Explain how you think temperature impacts whether you see snow or rain during a storm." They also analyze multiple graphs showing data from weather balloons (higher altitude and temperature) and refine their models. Whereas they analyze causal relationships, students are not required to name the type of relationship nor distinguish between causal and correlational relationships.

Examples of elements that materials do not address:

  • DATA-M8. Analyze data to define an optimal operational range for a proposed object, tool, process or system that best meets criteria for success.

Indicator 2e.v

1 / 2

Using Mathematics and Computational Thinking

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for using mathematics and computational thinking and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate four of the five elements of this practice with two elements partially incorporated; one element (MATH-M3) is missing. Across the series, students use elements of this SEP in each grade and each science discipline but have fewer opportunities to use elements of this SEP relative to other SEPs.

Examples of grade-band elements of Using Mathematics and Computational Thinking present in the materials:

  • MATH-M4. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Fire Extinguisher Go-Kart, students observe a go-kart traveling a distance of 300 feet and create a data table or graph of distance traveled over time if the go-kart traveled 15 miles per hour the entire time.

  • MATH-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 1, Lesson 5, Activity 12: Hands-On Engineering: Defining the Design Problem, students completing the fastest car challenge collect time data over a specified distance and use this measurement as a test of their design.

Examples of where materials partially incorporate grade-band elements of using mathematics and computational thinking:

  • MATH-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Displaying Data for Anchorage and Fairbanks, students are given 12 pieces of data and display this in a graph with an explanation. Whereas students are analyzing for patterns and trends, the data set is not large.

  • MATH-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 3, Activity 5: Why Not More?, students use symbols to represent how successful fruit flies are multiplying over generations. Whereas students use symbols, the representations are not used to describe nor support scientific conclusions and design solutions. 

Example of a grade-band element of using mathematics and computational thinking missing from the materials:

  • MATH-M3. Create algorithms (a series of ordered steps) to solve a problem.

Indicator 2e.vi

1 / 2

Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for constructing explanations and designing solutions and all grade-band elements across the series. Materials incorporate seven of the eight elements; one element (CEDS-M8) is missing from the materials. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to construct explanations or design solutions; students use elements of this SEP in each grade, in each science discipline, and in each unit, commonly using multiple elements of this SEP in each unit. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions present in the materials:

  • CEDS-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Dropped Objects, students state a claim, use evidence, and explain their reasoning of how air is acting on the levitating-orb system. They construct the explanation to include qualitative relationships between air and a dropped object that describes the phenomena.

  • CEDS-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 2, Activity 3: The Growing and Shrinking Appearance of the Moon, students continue with the changing appearance of the moon and the earth-sun-moon system from the previous activity by looking at a chart showing pictures of the moon on the same day at four different locations. They explain what they see and how it ties to the initial model they created. Students then gather more data from various graphs and create an explanation for how the interactions of the earth-sun-moon system create the changing appearance of the moon.

  • CEDS-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 5, Activity 16: River Transport, students apply learning from the unit to create a solution that will reduce or eliminate fish kills in the Delta. They begin by listing questions about what is causing the fish kill in the Delta that they need to answer with their solution. In groups, students complete the Student Engineering Design sheet, which requires students to define the problem. Considering and citing work that has already been done, they list possible solutions and consider available resources for its development. Lastly, they review others' ideas in a gallery walk and write an explanation about their solution including how it will work and how they would test it.

  • CEDS-M4. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 5, Activity 16: Freezing and Melting Point of Water, students draw a heating curve using information from the activity about the processes of state changes, including freezing and melting points. They complete a written explanation to accompany their drawing that explains energy flow and temperature patterns during each state change in the system.

  • CEDS-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 2, Activity 5, Modeling Squirrel Offspring, students develop models of genes and traits to construct an explanation about the inheritance of traits and how albino and gray squirrel siblings have inherited different traits. They use strips of paper with different symbol combinations to model how squirrels from the same parents may have different traits for ear shape, eye color, and tail type. Once data is recorded, they explain why their model squirrel siblings are similar or different. After comparing their models with the models of other groups, they explain the relationship between the symbols and the strips and genes, the combinations on each strip and chromosomes, and how the process of the investigation represents the inheritance of traits from parents to offspring. Students use their evidence to explain the difference in traits between albino and gray squirrel siblings.

  • CEDS-M6. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 14: Frozen Coils, students use  knowledge from previous lessons on air conditioner systems and heat transfer to design solutions to prevent the formation of ice on air conditioner coils. 

  • CEDS-M7. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students develop a design solution to keep the air conditioner from freezing and explain their ideas. They work together to create a list of criteria and constraints for solving this problem. Students choose which criteria and constraints to use in evaluating the possible systems and then choose the best solution based on its rating in the Pugh matrix.

Example of a grade-band element of using Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions missing from the materials:

  • CEDS-M8. Optimize performance of a design by prioritizing criteria, making tradeoffs, testing, revising, and retesting.

Indicator 2e.vii

1 / 2

Engaging in Argument from Evidence

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for engaging in argument from evidence and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate most grade-band elements across the series: one element (ARG-M4) is missing from the materials. Across the series, students use elements of this SEP in each grade, in each science discipline, and in half of the units across the series, with the ARG-M3 used most frequently. 

Examples of where materials incorporate engaging in argument from evidence:

  • ARG-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 3, Activity 7: Flowing Water, students create three models of watersheds and then, using evidence from the activity, decide which model they think is the best to explain the fish kills in the Delta. They write an explanation for why they think that model was the best representation and then compare their answers to a partner’s. When listening to their partner's choice and reasoning, they complete a chart that includes which model the partner chose, three pieces of evidence to support their choice, and if they interpreted facts the same or differently.

  • ARG-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Potential Attraction, students create models to show molecular movement across states and then exchange models in a small group. Using a rubric, they evaluate each model and share their feedback.

  • ARG-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 3, Activity 8: Embryological Development, students construct, use, and present to peers an argument as to what may have happened to surviving descendants of the mystery fossil. They support their argument with the evidence of fossil observations compared with the mystery fossil and an analysis of the world map over time showing a change in the environment. Students do not argue the solution to a problem. 

  • ARG-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 5, Activity 14: Testing a Scale Model, students construct and present an argument to support or refute a given claim as to the cause of the Hindenburg explosion. Throughout the unit, students investigate the conditions necessary for the burning of hydrogen and helium, observe videos of the effect of burning fabric under two different conditions, and watch video clips of possible causes of the Hindenburg explosion. They use this evidence, as well as scientific reasoning, to develop an argument. Students do not argue an explanation for a phenomenon.

  • ARG-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 3, Activity 12: Hands-On Engineering: 3-D Maglev Model, student teams use the engineering design process to design a simple, 3-D maglev system. Teams record agreed upon procedures and share their ideas and approaches with other teams. Discussions are used to improve their procedures prior to building their models.

  • ARG-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students develop a design solution to keep the air conditioner from freezing and explain their ideas. They work together to create a list of criteria and constraints for solving this problem. Students choose which criteria and constraints to use in evaluating the possible systems and then write an explanation specifically justifying their solution choice using the selected criteria and constraints.

Example of a grade-band element of using engaging in argument from evidence missing from the materials:

  • ARG-M4. Make an oral or written argument that supports or refutes the advertised performance of a device, process, or system, based on empirical evidence concerning whether or not the technology meets relevant criteria and constraints.

Indicator 2e.viii

1 / 2

Obtaining, Evaluating, and Communicating Information

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the science and engineering practices for obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials incorporate three elements of the practice and partially incorporate one element; one element (INFO-M4) is missing from the materials. Across the series, students use elements of this SEP in each grade and each science discipline, including this SEP multiple times in nearly all units.

Examples of grade-band elements of Obtaining, Evaluating, and Communicating Information present in the materials:

  • INFO-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 5, Activity 18: Analyzing Past Earthquakes, students research earthquakes in Puerto Rico and then create proposals for placing earthquake-detection monitoring stations. Sources used by students for this activity include an earthquake database from the internet, which students choose using a list of options curated by the teacher and maps of the Caribbean plate boundaries and trench systems in the activity. Using the patterns they notice about the location of the earthquakes and tectonic plates, they determine three to five locations to place earthquake detector systems that alert people in the Caribbean about earthquakes.

  • INFO-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 6, Activity 14: Getting Ready for the Storm, students collect information from text, images, maps, and videos to identify patterns and indicate what weather-related and natural hazards they may experience where they live. After this, students return to their initial models of the superstorm and explain how using more technology (like shown in the satellite images and maps) might help their models be more accurate.

  • INFO-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 5, Activity 15: Closer Look at Planetary Objects, students communicate scientific information in written or oral form of their research on a planetary object found in our solar system. They are not provided the opportunity to communicate about technical information.

  • INFO-M5. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 7, Activity 23: Light Sensors, students communicate technical information when they draw a model to explain how the light sensor system works and then how a light sensor works with a buzzer. The second model needs to include physical components of the system, non-physical components of the system such as how the sound from the buzzer reaches your ear and how light is traveling to the photocell, the behavior of the sound when the photocell is receiving the maximum light energy, and when the photocell is receiving decreased light energy.

Example where materials partially incorporate elements of obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information:

  • INFO-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 6, Activity 21: Which Signal is Better?, students conduct research from multiple resources and summarize the main idea from each. They answer the prompt of why scientists use multiple, reliable sources and list examples of reliable and unreliable sources. Students write a script telling a story to answer their own research question. They do not discuss bias of information or methods used in this activity.

Example of the element of obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information missing from the materials:

  • INFO-M4. Evaluate data, hypotheses, and/or conclusions in scientific and technical texts in light of competing information or accounts.

Indicator 2f

Narrative Only

Materials incorporate all grade-band Crosscutting Concepts.

Indicator 2f.i

2 / 2

Patterns

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept (CCC) of patterns and all grade-band elements across the series. Elements of patterns are found in all units. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to engage with the CCC of patterns; students use elements of this CCC in each grade, in each science discipline, and in each unit, commonly using multiple elements of this CCC in each unit. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Patterns present in the materials:

  • PAT-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 3, Activity 9: It’s a Matter of Atoms, students use the macroscopic patterns identified in given chemical reactions related to electrolysis and the burning of hydrogen and methane in order to predict how molecules (atomic-level structure) interact (e.g., reactants and products) due to the burning of propane.

  • PAT-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Sunlight Time, students interpret data from graphs on the seasonal increase in kelp length and carbon content in kelp. They discuss patterns observed in the graphs to explain the relationship between energy from the sun and the flow of matter into kelp to understand the natural system. 

  • PAT-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 9, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Analyzing and Interpreting Data for Anchorage and Fairbanks, students identify patterns observed in student-created graphs of temperature and snowfall data and determine what the pattern allows them to conclude about the amount of snow in one place versus another.

  • PAT-M4. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 2: Earthquake Data, students review a map of earthquake occurrence in Puerto Rico. After answering questions, students compare two different maps, explaining how the new information can be used to identify patterns related to aftershocks. Specifically, students are asked: “How can analyzing different maps of a region help you better understand natural events, such as earthquakes?”

Indicator 2f.ii

2 / 2

Cause and Effect

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept (CCC) of cause and effect and all grade-band elements across the series. Of the three grade-band elements of cause and effect, two are fully incorporated, and one is partially incorporated. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to engage with this CCC; students use elements of this CCC in each grade, in each science discipline, and in nearly all units. The element most frequently incorporated is CE-M2. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Cause and Effect present in the materials:

  • CE-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 6, Activity 15: Hands-On Investigation: Greenhouse Effect, students create a model, gather data to understand the greenhouse effect, and explain how the results can be used to address the cause for and need to move the starting location of the dogsled race. Students select statements that answer "how do you think an increase in greenhouse gases in the atmosphere will affect the amount of snow in Alaska?” and “how does this contribute to the lack of snow on parts of the dogsled race route?"

  • CE-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 6, Activity 13: Before and After, students compare their predictions for weather with actual conditions and discuss how meteorologists use probability when predicting the weather. 

Example of a grade-band element of Cause and Effect partially present in the materials:

  • CE-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Hydrogen Burning, students explore the conditions necessary for the burning of hydrogen. They use evidence to support or refute the claim that hydrogen was the main cause of the Hindenburg explosion. There is a missed opportunity for students to identify relationships that are correlated and to differentiate between causation and correlation.

Indicator 2f.iii

0 / 2

Scale, Proportion, and Quantity

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 do not meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept of scale, proportion, and quantity and all grade-band elements across the series. Three of the five grade-band elements are incorporated across the series, and two (SPQ-M2 and SPQ-M4) are missing from the materials. Students have repeated opportunities to engage with this CCC in multiple units, using elements of this CCC in each grade and each science discipline. Within some units, students engage with multiple elements of this CCC.

Examples of grade-band elements of Scale, Proportion, and Quantity present in the materials:

  • SPQ-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 13, Lesson 2, Activity 6: A Time for Everything, students read a brief introduction that discusses the difficulty of visualizing time on a large scale and why scale models are used. They record examples of scale models that they may have used or seen and watch an animation about scale models. Students use materials to create a consensus scale model of earth’s history. They relate information from previous lessons to their model, what they’ve figured out about a mystery fossil’s place within their model, and identify the next step to identifying the mystery fossil.

  • SPQ-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 5, Activity 13: Albinism in Offspring, students analyze a data table on the Olney squirrel population, calculate the percent of the population that is albino, and explain the occurrence of albinism within the population. Using knowledge from modeling inheritance of genes, the relationship between type of reproduction and likelihood of mutations, students explain the smaller percentage of albino squirrels in the Olney squirrel population and why more genetic variation is seen in organisms that reproduce sexually. 

  • SPQ-M5. In Grade 6, Unit 4, Lesson 1, Activity 1: Skateboard Mishap, students are asked to compare what they can observe by looking at the surface of the skin to what they cannot observe with their eyes, why their current observations of the healing cut are limited, and how might they make additional observations that they cannot make by just looking at the skin. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Scale, Proportion, and Quantity not present in the materials:

  • SPQ-M2. The observed function of natural and designed systems may change with scale.

  • SPQ-M4. Scientific relationships can be represented through the use of algebraic expressions and equations.

Indicator 2f.iv

2 / 2

Systems and System Models

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept of systems and system models and all grade-band elements across the series. Across the series, students have repeated opportunities to engage with this CCC; students use elements of this CCC in each grade and in each science discipline. Elements of this CCC are used in all sixth grade units and less frequently in the other grades. The elements SYS-M1 and SYS-M2 are incorporated more frequently than SYS-M3.


Examples of grade-band elements of Systems and System Models present in the materials:

  • SYS-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 4, Activity 12: How an Air Conditioner Cools, Part 2, students review and analyze models of the various subsystems in an air conditioner and identify how they work together in the larger system. 

  • SYS-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 7, Lesson 2, Activity 8: Modeling Photosynthesis, students refine a working model of a kelp forest ecosystem to show the interactions of the components of that ecosystem, including the process of photosynthesis. Student models of photosynthesis show the input components of carbon dioxide, water, and sunlight, resulting in the outputs of oxygen and sugar, and energy and matter flow.

  • SYS-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 1, Activity 5: Gravity at Different Scales, students evaluate the limitations of their model and write about parts of the system they have not fully represented.

Indicator 2f.v

2 / 2

Energy and Matter

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept of energy and matter and all grade-band elements across the series. Across the series, students have multiple opportunities to engage with this CCC; students use elements of this CCC in each grade and in each science discipline. Students engage with elements of this CCC in two or three units per grade, most frequently in physical science units.

Examples of grade-band elements of Energy and Matter present in the materials:

  • EM-M1. In Grade 7, Unit 6, Lesson 4, Activity 13: Hands-On Investigation: Energy Lab, students continue their investigations on chemical reactions to understand how they take in energy or give off energy. They record what they think happened with energy during the Hindenburg explosion and list questions they have related to energy as a result of a demonstration in a previous lesson. Prior to viewing a video clip, students predict the outcome of a chemical reaction involving barium hydroxide octahydrate and solid ammonium chloride and then record observations. Students use provided materials as they plan and conduct an investigation to collect data about how energy changes during chemical reactions.  

  • EM-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Changing Continents, students read about the conditions within the earth that result in either liquid or solid material then observe a demonstration model of the processes that drive the movement of continents.   After proving their initial thoughts as to how plates move, students use their observations to explain how energy transfers in a natural system and how this energy is driving the motion and cycling of matter.

  • EM-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 5, Activity 21: Energy Transfer, students describe where energy is stored, used, and transferred in the junkyard-magnetic-paperclip system and compare the potential energy in this system to the potential energy in a rubber band system.

  • EM-M4. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 3, Activity 6: The Water Cycle, students write a story about the journey of a water droplet in the water cycle. They revisit their stories throughout the activity with prompts to change the scenario (you landed somewhere the air temperature remains below freezing all year or you landed somewhere you were absorbed into the ground). After thinking through these different scenarios, students return to their initial story and add in more information to include how the transfer of energy influences the path water takes as it falls from the sky. They apply their understanding of the water cycle to help them explain what happened in the Superstorm.

Indicator 2f.vi

2 / 2

Structure and Function

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept of structure and function and all grade-band elements across the series. Across the series, students engage with this CCC in multiple units; students use elements of this CCC in sixth and eighth grade and primarily in life science units. 

Examples of grade-band elements of Structure and Function present in the materials:

  • SF-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 3, Activity 7: Making Melanin, students investigate the complex system of the role of proteins in the development of the pigment melanin. They model the complex and microscopic structures and systems to describe how protein structure can determine their function.

  • SF-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 3, Activity 12: Three-D Maglev Model, students use the engineering process to design a three-dimensional maglev system and take into account the properties of the materials provided. They then explain how the structure of one of the used items provides an important function for the overall system.

Indicator 2f.vii

1 / 2

Stability and Change

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 partially meet expectations that they incorporate the crosscutting concept of stability and change and all grade-band elements across the series. The materials include nearly all of the grade-band elements across the series; one of the four elements (SC-M4) is missing in the materials. Across the series, students engage with this CCC in multiple units; students use elements of this CCC in Grade 7 and Grade 8 and within life science earth and space science units. 


Examples of grade-band elements of Stability and Change present in the materials:

  • SC-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 4, Activity 9: Modeling Speciation, students examine environmental changes and pressures over time at levels of the cell and organism. They then construct an explanation as to how 800 species of fruit flies could have derived from a single fruit fly over millions of years.

  • SC-M2. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 3, Activity 9: Nutrients and Human Health, students read a passage and answer questions that ask about the impacts of one small change on larger changes. Questions include discussing how groundwater has changed over the long term due to human activity, what factors could make this system unstable (such as amounts of nitrogen in groundwater), and what length of time frame did it take for changes to occur (gradual or sudden). After answering these questions, students return to their models of the fish kill in the Delta and add information about the factors of stability and change related to the phenomenon.

  • SC-M3. In Grade 7, Unit 10, Lesson 16: Fossil Fuels and Greenhouse Gases, students are asked to use what they have learned about greenhouse gases and fossil fuels to construct an explanation about how fossil fuels affect the atmosphere and temperatures on earth as well as in Alaska specifically. They support the explanation with evidence from the provided graphs that include data from 1900-2018. This activity does not address changes due to sudden events.

  • SC-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 15, Lesson 1, Activity 1: Earthquake in the News, students watch a video of the effects of a sudden earthquake and observe an image of a stable rock arch before and after the same earthquake. They use these observations to show how the effects of the earthquake changed the natural structure. This activity does not address gradual changes over time.

Example of a grade-band element of Stability and Change not present in the materials:

  • SC-M4. Systems in dynamic equilibrium are stable due to a balance of feedback mechanisms.

Indicator 2g

2 / 2

Materials incorporate NGSS Connections to Nature of Science and Engineering.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grades 6-8 meet expectations that they incorporate NGSS connections to the nature of science (NOS) and engineering (ENG). Across the series, materials incorporate most components and many elements of the grade-band NGSS connections. The NOS and engineering elements are represented and attended multiple times throughout the grade-band units. They are used in correlation with the content and not used as isolated lessons. 


Examples of grade-band connections to NOS elements associated with SEPs present in the materials:

  • NOS-VOM-M1 . In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Hands-On Investigation: Rubber Band Sounds, the activity planning document includes instructions for small groups of students to discuss the variety of methods and tools they have used in their investigations, where measurements and observations are collected, and to describe the benefit of using different methods and tools when they plan and carry out investigations.

  • NOS-BEE-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 2, Activity 4: Human Dependence on Water, students analyze data on fisheries in the Gulf of Mexico. Students share how they can use all of this evidence to explain why fisheries are nationally important. The materials guide teachers to support students’ understanding of the use of evidence in scientific explanations by asking why it is important to base explanations on evidence and not opinion.

  • NOS-OTR-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 16, Lesson 4, Activity 12: Farming and Extinctions, students reflect on the flow chart and models they made to explain the dead fish in the delta. During this reflection, teachers ask students to share how their understandings have changed throughout the unit when given new evidence. Specifically, teachers ask: “How has the evidence you have gathered from your observations helped you improve your initial mind map?” and “Why is it important to keep revising scientific findings?”

  • NOS-OTR-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 12, Lesson 2, Activity 6: Gray or White?, students analyze the structure and function of protein molecules then write questions they have about how the structure of genes and proteins are connected to their functions. Students refine their flowchart models to show how proteins relate to genes and observable traits. After their own revisions, students then discuss in small groups why it is important for scientists to continually revise their understanding.

Examples of grade-band connections to NOS elements associated with CCCs present in the materials:

  • NOS-WOK-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Potential Attraction, students prepare to peer review heat curve models. Materials prompt the teacher to explain the peer review process in science, usually through article publication, where other scientists provide feedback, decide if the methods and data are valid, and determine if it should be published. The teacher provides sentence stems for the students to provide constructive and respectful feedback, and students use this as a way to improve their models. Students who disagree with a comment from others provide an evidence-based argument for not making the revisions.

  • NOS-WOK-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 2, Activity 5: Gravity at Different Scales, the activity planning document includes the discussion prompt, “Why can scientists today still use the work of Newton and Cavendish to understand gravity?” The instructions prompt the teacher to use student responses in guiding them to consider the words law and theory as they apply to gravity.

  • NOS-AOC-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 2, Lesson 5, Activity 20: Let it Glow!, the activity planning document includes directions for students to explore and discuss how the nature of science applies to the invention of designed devices, such as batteries and capacitors. Students connect the invention of these devices to the assumption that electric fields and forces operate consistently in different systems.

  • NOS-HE-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students return to the anchoring phenomenon first presented in the unit. As they have solved the problem of the air conditioner, they help solve the issue of ice forming on the inside of the window. In preparing for this activity, the teacher tells the students that they will continue to work as scientists and engineers, which involves persistence, precision, reasoning, logic, imagination and creativity to solve real-world problems.

  • NOS-HE-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 5, Activity 17: Fuel for Healing, students read a passage about the interaction of organ systems during cellular respiration and identify evidence they could use to strengthen their initial claim. Using habit of mind, tolerance of ambiguity, and openness to new ideas, students share their ideas with peers, who may have differing ideas. Students can change their ideas based upon this interaction with peers.

Examples of grade-band connections to ENG elements associated with CCCs present in the materials:

  • ENG-INFLU-M1. In Grade 8, Unit 10, Lesson 8, Activity 21: Constructing Explanations, the activity planning document includes instructions to have students reflect on what they have figured out about the positive and negative consequences of human activity on the health of people and the natural environment.

  • ENG-INFLU-M2. In Grade 6, Unit 3, Lesson 6, Activity 20: Unit Project: Unwanted Frost on the Window, students construct an explanation for why the ice is forming on the interior of a window. After creating an explanation for the cause, students brainstorm possible solutions to prevent the ice from forming. Once solutions have been created, students regroup to evaluate them based on the Pugh Matrix. Teachers explain to students that engineers have to account for many factors (needs, research findings, and economics) when designing solutions and one way to capture the criteria and constraints to determine the best solution is through using the Pugh Matrix.

  • ENG-INFLU-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 11, Lesson 3, Activity 10: Hands-On Investigation: Rubber Band Sounds, the activity planning document includes instructions to have students reflect on the statement, “Technology use varies over time and from region to region.” Materials include other discussion prompts for teachers to use in follow up to this reflection where students describe the benefits of using different tools with investigations. 

  • ENG-INTER-M2. In Grade 7, Unit 8, Lesson 2, Activity 8: Zebra Migration Patterns, students read about scientists investigating how a large zebra population behaved during wet season months when resources varied in their home range. Scientists fitted several female zebras with tracking collars. Along with the collars, GPS technology and satellites were used to monitor the zebras’ exact location. Students discuss in small groups how the collars drive understanding science of zebra behavior and how the science might drive the development of the technology.

  • ENG-INTER-M3. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 2, Activity 4: A Whole New Leg?, students discuss how technologies influence scientists' understanding as to how salamanders have the ability to regrow limbs. They answer one prompt about how the technology led to the knowledge of special cells in the salamander leg and another prompt on how technology allows for information to be presented, for example, through the internet.

Examples of where materials partially incorporate grade-band connections to nature of science and engineering: 

  • NOS-AQAW-M3. In Grade 8, Unit 14, Lesson 5, Activity 11: The koa tree and the Kauaʻi fruit fly, students explain the effect of the destruction of the Koa tree for plantation development on the Kauaʻi fruit fly population. Students do not explore how science knowledge is responsible for society’s decisions.

  • ENG-INTER-M1. In Grade 6, Unit 5, Lesson 2, Activity 3: Under the Microscopes, students observe microscopic images and discuss how the invention of the microscope has influenced scientific knowledge of living things. Explicit exploration into the development of industries or engineered systems is not included.